Size Premium based on the STOXX Europe 600®

The size premium is an add-on to the cost of equity of smaller companies. It is based on the assumption that smaller companies bear higher risks than large ones, for example due to lower diversification, more limited access to capital markets and lower liquidity of their shares. Investors therefore require a higher return. In valuation practice, the size premium is often added to the risk-free rate, the market risk premium and the beta factor when calculating the cost of capital.

The literature takes differing views on the level and stability of the size premium (Damodaran, 2015). The premium varies considerably over time and is often highly local. It can also be partly explained by other factors, such as illiquidity or a concentration on microcaps.

Whether a size premium should be applied must therefore be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

As a basis for this assessment, we provide users with two analyses based on the STOXX Europe 600®:

  • the historical size premium based on realised returns
  • the implied (forward) size premium based on current market prices

Historical Size Premium

We derive the historical size premium from the difference between the annual returns of the STOXX Europe Small 200 and the STOXX Europe Large 200. If the value is positive, smaller companies have earned an excess return (size premium). If it is negative, they have performed worse than large companies (size discount).

For most years since 2000, the size premium is positive. Negative values appear in 2008 and in the years 2022 to 2026. Possible reasons for this include:

  • a “flight to quality” towards large, liquid companies during periods of crisis
  • the greater burden on smaller companies from rising interest rates (since 2022)
  • a difficult macroeconomic environment in Europe

The results show that the historical size premium depends heavily on the period under review. Long-term averages should therefore be used with caution.

The following chart shows the development of the size premium based on the approach described above:

Disclaimer
The information presented in this overview has been compiled from publicly available sources and is provided for informational purposes only. For binding information as of a specific date, please contact the person listed below. Grant Thornton Austria assumes no liability for the data used. The use of this data is permitted exclusively for non-commercial purposes.

Implied (Forward) Size Premium

The implied size premium shows whether, as of the respective valuation date, the capital market prices in a higher return for smaller companies. We use the same approach as for our implied market returns (see Capital Market Parameters). A multi-period dividend discount model (DDM) gives us the implied returns of the STOXX Europe Large 200 and the STOXX Europe Small 200, using data from the financial data provider S&P Capital IQ. The model uses the aggregated free-float market capitalizations of the companies in each index and consensus dividend forecasts based on analyst estimates. The implied size premium is then calculated as the difference between the two implied returns.

The categorization of the STOXX Europe 600 constituents into three equally sized groups of 200 companies each is based on the STOXX Index Methodology. In addition, we also use the Morningstar Style Box Methodology. Under this methodology, companies are categorized according to their cumulative free-float market capitalization, with Large Caps representing approximately 70%, Mid Caps the subsequent 20%, and Small Caps the remaining 10% of total free-float market capitalization.

The calculation is performed at each month-end. We analyze both the overall market and the 11 sectors of the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS®). We excluded the real estate sector due to an insufficient number of reference companies.

A positive value (size premium) indicates that the market requires a higher return for smaller companies. A value close to zero or below tends to argue against a general size add-on. In that case, size-specific risks can instead be reflected in the business plan.

The following chart shows the development of the implied size premium based on the approach described above:

Select data set:

Disclaimer
The information presented in this overview has been compiled from publicly available sources and is provided for informational purposes only. For binding information as of a specific date, please contact the person listed below. Grant Thornton Austria assumes no liability for the data used. The use of this data is permitted exclusively for non-commercial purposes.